7 Must-Watch Movies Like Totally Killer for Thrills | Similar-List

If Totally Killer captivated you with its exhilarating fusion of horror and comedy, you're in for a treat! We've compiled a selection of films that mirror this unique blend, offering a perfect mix of frights and laughs to keep your Halloween spirit alive and well.

Totally Killer is a standout in the horror-comedy genre, skillfully combining elements of both to create a cinematic experience that’s both thrilling and amusing. The film’s innovative storytelling and engaging characters make it an essential watch for anyone who loves their scares with a side of humor.

Set 35 years after the notorious “Sweet 16 Killer” claimed the lives of three teenagers on their 16th birthdays, Totally Killer follows 17-year-old Jamie Hughes (Kiernan Shipka) as she inadvertently travels back to 1987. Joined by her teenage mother, Jamie must prevent further murders and find her way back to the present. The film’s blend of time travel, slasher thrills, and sharp-witted humor keeps viewers engrossed from start to finish.

If Totally Killer left you wanting more, we've curated a list of films that share a similar horror-comedy vibe. Whether through time-travel twists, slasher scenarios, or clever humor, these movies will keep the thrills and laughter going strong.

7 Must-Watch Movies Like Totally Killer for Thrills

Sorority Row (2009)

If the chilling blend of horror and comedy in Totally Killer left you craving more, you might find Sorority Row a compelling addition to your watchlist. This film, a modern reimagining of the 1982 slasher classic The House on Sorority Row, serves up its dose of terror and intrigue.

Sorority Row kicks off with a group of Theta Pi sorority sisters at Rosman University, who accidentally caused the death of one of their own during a prank gone awry. In a desperate attempt to cover up the incident, the group tries to bury their secret, but their efforts to keep it hidden set off a chain of events that spirals out of control.

Months later, on graduation night, the sorority sisters are hunted down by a masked killer seeking revenge for the incident they tried to conceal. The film immerses viewers in a world of suspense and gore, with each scene brimming with tension and bloodshed. The ensemble cast, including Briana Evigan, Leah Pipes, Rumer Willis, Jamie Chung, and Carrie Fisher, delivers gripping performances that amplify the film's horror elements.

Sorority Row and Totally Killer share a common thread in their slasher themes and female-centric narratives. Both films focus on young protagonists facing off against relentless killers, combining suspenseful horror with moments of intense drama. The visceral violence and the dynamic between the characters in Sorority Row resonate with the horror and tension found in Totally Killer.

Unlike Totally Killer, Sorority Row does not incorporate any elements of time travel or comedy. Instead, it leans heavily into traditional slasher tropes, with a plot driven by revenge and a series of brutal murders. The humor is minimal, and the tone is darker and more straightforward in its approach to horror.

Fans of Totally Killer will appreciate Sorority Row for its engaging plot and relentless suspense. While it may lack the time-travel twist and comedic undertones of Totally Killer, it compensates with a strong focus on horror and an intriguing storyline centered around a group of young women facing a life-threatening crisis. If you enjoyed the thrills and chills of Totally Killer, Sorority Row will keep you hooked with its gripping narrative and shocking twists.

The Slumber Party Massacre (1982)

For those who revel in the mix of slasher thrills and dark humor found in Totally Killer, The Slumber Party Massacre is a must-see. This cult classic delivers its brand of horror while nodding to the slasher genre’s roots.

The Slumber Party Massacre, directed by Amy Holden Jones, presents a chilling yet somewhat tongue-in-cheek take on the slasher genre. The film is a quintessential 80s slasher that combines suspenseful storytelling with a touch of satire, making it a standout in its category.

The film centers on a group of teenage girls who gather for a slumber party, only to find their fun disrupted by a sadistic killer armed with a power drill. The story follows the harrowing events of the night as the girls fight for survival against a relentless and mysterious murderer. The film’s blend of graphic violence and dark humor offers an engaging viewing experience that keeps audiences on the edge of their seats.

The Slumber Party Massacre shares several similarities with Totally Killer, particularly in its homage to slasher conventions and its focus on a group of young women confronting a horrifying threat. Both films combine suspense and horror elements with a strong female cast, creating a thrilling experience that taps into the fears and anxieties of their characters. The slasher format and the focus on survival against a killer will resonate with fans of Totally Killer.

While The Slumber Party Massacre excels in classic slasher horror, it lacks the time-travel twist and comedic elements in Totally Killer. Instead, it leans into the traditional slasher formula, emphasizing gruesome kills and a straightforward plot. The humor in The Slumber Party Massacre is more subtle and often derived from its over-the-top horror elements rather than being an integral part of the narrative.

Fans of Totally Killer will find The Slumber Party Massacre a nostalgic and entertaining ride through slasher horror. Its blend of suspense, violence, and dark humor offers a different but complementary experience to the time-traveling and comedic thrills of Totally Killer. If you enjoy films that celebrate and subvert classic horror tropes while delivering an engaging and intense experience, The Slumber Party Massacre deserves a spot on your watchlist.

Add The Slumber Party Massacre to your viewing lineup for a dose of classic slasher horror that pairs well with the excitement of Totally Killer.

The Babysitter (2017)

If Totally Killer thrilled you with its mix of slasher elements and humor, then The Babysitter is a film you won’t want to miss. This 2017 horror-comedy combines suspense with dark humor, creating an entertaining experience perfect for fans of quirky, thrilling narratives.

Directed by McG, The Babysitter stands out for its blend of teen comedy and horror. The film embraces its genre roots while infusing it with a playful yet suspenseful tone. Its unique approach and charismatic cast make it a notable entry in the horror-comedy genre.

The film centers around Cole (Judah Lewis), a 12-year-old boy who discovers that his seemingly perfect babysitter, Bee (Samara Weaving), is a satanic cult leader. When a night of babysitting turns into a deadly game, Cole must use his wits and bravery to survive the night. The film's blend of shocking twists and comedic elements creates a dynamic, engaging story that keeps viewers on edge.

Much like Totally Killer, The Babysitter mixes horror with comedy, offering a thrilling and entertaining experience. Both films feature young protagonists caught in terrifying situations, where humor is used to lighten the horror elements. The Babysitter shares the same sense of fun and irreverence, making it a fitting recommendation for fans of Totally Killer.

While Totally Killer involves time travel and integrates significant comedy into its slasher framework, The Babysitter focuses on a single night of intense horror and dark humor. The film's narrative is driven by the discovery of a cult rather than time-traveling escapades, and its comedic elements often stem from the absurdity of the situation and the exaggerated characters. This creates a different, yet complementary, experience to the blend of thrills and laughs found in Totally Killer.

If you appreciated the humor and horror blend of Totally Killer, The Babysitter will likely resonate with you. Its engaging plot, charismatic cast, and clever twists ensure a captivating viewing experience. The film's ability to balance scares with dark comedy makes it a standout choice for those seeking a similar mix of thrills and laughs.

Add The Babysitter to your watchlist for a dose of high-energy horror-comedy that aligns well with the spirit of Totally Killer. Its unique take on the genre and entertaining storyline will keep you hooked from beginning to end.

Happy Death Day (2017)

For those who enjoyed the blend of humor and horror in Totally Killer, Happy Death Day offers a similarly thrilling and comedic experience. This 2017 film combines the best elements of slasher and dark comedy, making it a standout choice for fans of this genre fusion.

Directed by Christopher Landon, Happy Death Day redefines the slasher genre with its inventive approach and engaging storyline. The film features a fresh twist on the time-loop concept, delivering both scares and laughs equally.

The story follows Tree Gelbman (Jessica Rothe), a college student who finds herself stuck in a time loop, repeatedly reliving the day of her murder. Each iteration presents Tree with a new way to meet her end, driving her to uncover her killer's identity and break the cycle. As she navigates the dangers of her predicament, the film skillfully balances suspense with dark humor, making each loop thrilling and entertaining.

Happy Death Day shares several similarities with Totally Killer, especially in its approach to mixing horror with humor. Both films use time manipulation as a central plot device, blending slasher elements with comedic moments to create an engaging viewing experience. The protagonists in each film are thrust into high-stakes scenarios where humor provides a counterbalance to the horror, enhancing the overall appeal of the narrative.

While Totally Killer involves literal time travel to solve a series of murders, Happy Death Day employs a time-loop mechanism. This distinction shifts the focus from a traditional time travel narrative to a repetitive day that must be overcome. The humor in Happy Death Day arises from Tree’s repeated experiences and growing awareness of her situation's absurdity rather than the historical or genre-bending twists seen in Totally Killer. This unique approach offers a different yet complementary take on the horror-comedy genre.

If you found Totally Killer entertaining, Happy Death Day is a must-watch. Its inventive plot and successful integration of horror with dark comedy make it a compelling choice for fans of the genre. The film’s clever narrative and engaging performances keep viewers invested from start to finish, ensuring a satisfying experience that echoes the thrills and laughs of Totally Killer.

Add Happy Death Day to your movie list for a dose of time-loop intrigue mixed with horror and humor. It’s an excellent follow-up for those who enjoyed the energetic and unique blend of scares and comedy found in Totally Killer.

Freaky (2020)

If Totally Killer captivated you with its blend of horror and comedy, then Freaky is another film you’ll want to add to your watchlist. Released in 2020, Freaky takes a unique approach by combining body-swapping with slasher elements, creating a fresh, entertaining spin on the horror-comedy genre.

Directed by Christopher Landon, Freaky delivers a hilarious yet chilling experience. It merges the thrill of a slasher film with the comedic chaos of body-swapping. The film stars Kathryn Newton and Vince Vaughn in a role reversal that adds an extra layer of humor to the horror.

The story centers around Millie Kessler (Kathryn Newton), a high school student who becomes the target of the Blissfield Butcher (Vince Vaughn), a notorious serial killer. After a brutal encounter, Millie and the Butcher accidentally switch bodies. With just 24 hours to reverse the curse before Millie is trapped in the Butcher’s body forever, she must navigate the challenges of high school life while being hunted by her friends and family, who are now in peril.

Freaky and Totally Killer share a common thread in their genre-blending approach, combining horror with comedic elements to create an engaging and entertaining experience. Both films feature protagonists who must navigate terrifying situations with a humorous twist. In Freaky, the body-swapping plot adds a unique comedic angle, similar to how Killer uses time travel to infuse humor into its slasher narrative.

While Totally Killer relies on a time-travel mechanism to navigate its slasher plot, Freaky introduces body-swapping as its central gimmick. This difference creates a unique narrative dynamic, as Millie must contend with the challenges of living in someone else’s body while trying to prevent more murders. The humor in Freaky comes from the juxtaposition of Millie’s teenage struggles with the Butcher’s evil persona. In contrast, through its time-travel framework, Totally Killer blends humor with historical and slasher elements.

For fans of Totally Killer, Freaky offers a similarly entertaining mix of scares and laughs. The film’s inventive plot and standout performances by Kathryn Newton and Vince Vaughn make it a memorable addition to the horror-comedy genre. The body-swapping twist provides a fresh perspective on familiar tropes, ensuring that viewers are entertained and intrigued.

If you enjoyed the playful yet chilling atmosphere of Totally Killer, Freaky will continue to deliver with its inventive narrative and comedic flair. Don’t miss out on this fun and frightful film that captures the essence of horror-comedy with a unique twist.

Truth or Dare (2017)

If Totally Killer left you craving more thrills that blend horror with a touch of dark humor, then Truth or Dare is a must-see. This 2017 film offers a captivating and chilling take on a classic party game gone awry, ensuring a gripping experience for fans of the horror-comedy genre.

Directed by Jeff Wadlow, Truth or Dare transforms the innocent party game into a deadly survival game. Starring Lucy Hale and Tyler Posey, the film injects suspense and dread into a seemingly simple game, making it a fresh and exciting addition to the horror genre.

The story begins with a group of college friends vacationing in Mexico. During their trip, they play a game of Truth or Dare, only to discover that a sinister force possesses the game. They are forced to confront their deepest secrets and darkest fears as they continue to play. The game escalates quickly, leading to deadly consequences if they fail to answer truthfully or refuse a dare. The stakes are life and death, turning their vacation into a nightmare.

Truth or Dare shares the horror-comedy blend that fans of Totally Killer will appreciate. Both films incorporate a unique twist on classic horror elements—Totally Killer's time-travel slasher narrative and Truth or Dare with a vicious game. The tension and high stakes in Truth or Dare echo the suspenseful yet playful atmosphere of Totally Killer, offering a mix of fear and fun.

Unlike Totally Killer, which utilizes time travel to interweave its narrative, Truth or Dare focuses on a supernatural game that forces participants to face their worst fears. The film’s horror is more psychological, driven by the game’s demands rather than supernatural entities or historical twists. The comedic elements in Truth or Dare are more subdued than the humor found in Totally Killer, often derived from its time-traveling protagonist's awkward situations.

Fans of Totally Killer will find Truth or Dare a thrilling addition to their watchlist. The film’s unique premise and intense stakes create a suspenseful atmosphere, while the game’s supernatural elements add an eerie twist. Lucy Hale delivers a standout performance as she navigates the terrifying game, adding depth and intensity to the narrative.

If you enjoyed the mix of horror and humor in Totally Killer, Truth or Dare will continue to engage with its innovative premise and high tension. Dive into this chilling game of survival and see how long you can live against Truth or Dare's deadly demands.

The Final Girls (2015)

For fans of Totally Killer seeking a unique blend of horror and heartfelt nostalgia, The Final Girls offers a fresh and entertaining experience. This 2015 film cleverly intertwines slasher horror with a touching story about family and friendship, delivering both scares and emotional depth.

Directed by Todd Strauss-Schulson, The Final Girls is a meta-horror film that pays homage to 80s slasher flicks while adding a modern twist. Starring Taissa Farmiga, Malin Akerman, and Adam Devine, the film stands out for its inventive narrative and ability to blend genres seamlessly.

The story centers on Max Cartwright (Taissa Farmiga), who, along with her friends, is magically transported into her late mother’s most famous movie, Camp Bloodbath, an 80s slasher classic. As they navigate the film’s campy horror tropes, Max and her friends must find a way to save her mother, who starred as the film’s final girl, while also surviving the murderous rampage of the film’s masked killer. The film cleverly mixes time travel and meta-commentary elements as the characters interact with the slasher film’s clichés and try to rewrite their fate.

The Final Girls shares several thematic elements with Totally Killer. Both films feature characters thrust into a slasher scenario to confront terrifying events. The playful yet chilling atmosphere in The Final Girls echoes the blend of humor and horror seen in Totally Killer. Additionally, the meta-horror elements and nostalgic nods in The Final Girls offer a creative twist similar to the innovative approach of Totally Killer.

While Totally Killer involves literal time travel to alter past events, The Final Girls operates within a film-within-a-film concept. The characters are not traveling through time but interacting with a fictional narrative from within. This results in a different type of engagement with the horror genre—more self-aware and nostalgic, focusing on classic slasher tropes rather than a direct time-travel plot. The emotional core of The Final Girls, centered around Max’s relationship with her late mother, adds a layer of sentimentality that contrasts with the comedic and time-travel elements of Totally Killer.

For those who enjoyed Totally Killer's time-travel and slasher elements, The Final Girls offers a unique and entertaining spin on the genre. The film’s clever blend of humor, horror, and heartfelt moments creates a dynamic viewing experience. With its nostalgic references and meta-commentary, The Final Girls provides a refreshing take on the slasher film, making it a worthy addition to your watchlist.

If you loved the mix of thrills and humor in Totally Killer, you’ll find The Final Girls an engaging and creative film that honors and deconstructs the slasher genre. Dive into this meta-horror experience and enjoy the blend of scares, laughs, and heartfelt moments.

For fans of Totally Killer seeking more thrilling and humorous cinematic experiences, these films offer a range of options. Each movie provides a unique take on blending horror with comedy, from inventive plot twists to classic slasher elements.

Explore these films to extend your journey into horror and comedy. Share your favorite films and thoughts in the comments below, and continue discovering similar content to keep the fun and frights going beyond Totally Killer.